Island29 wrote:
No way, I NEVER said that, she was GREAT as Fiona that is why I was so shocked at her overacting in "Nowhere Boy". 
  
Thanks for clarifying, island. It sounded from your first post that you thought she was 'just OK' in most of the stuff you've seen her in.
I also wondered whether the type of part she played in 'Nowhere Boy'--i.e., a manic depressive--made it seem like she was overacting in her manic phases. Knowing someone who is bi-polar, I can see how manic can look like 'overacting.'